It's been a while since I posted, and I feel the need to vent slightly. Also, to introduce a concept that a friend and I are going to work on.
This all spurred from a little debate on Google Buzz amongst friends, and I've decided that I'm kinda sick of it. I know that for a while Microsoft did commercials on it, and am of a mind to contact them to help me in my quest. Ultimately, what happened is someone claimed that they love using a Mac because "It just works". It's kind of a cop-out of an argument, as you could make that claim with ANYTHING when it is running. If I threw it off a 3-story balcony, it probably wouldn't still "just work". Not that almost any electronic appliance would (save perhaps a Motorola/Nextel phone, I've seen those take a SERIOUS beating), but my point is that this is hardly a valid argument for it. So, let us analyze some of the concepts and arguments in this long-running debate. Do note before we begin that I am partial, but not closed-minded. This is not intended to be a mac-hate rant, but to help the layman make an educated decision before they make a purchase. My personal feeling is that the Macbook Pro is an excellent system, but I do not believe it the end-all computer solution for people like it is marketed to be. I think it is overpriced for what you get, and you could do MUCH better with the proper PC laptop.
I made the statement in this conversation that a computer is a computer is a computer. And it really is. If you tear apart a TI-83, you will probably find a lot of the same Motorola chips that you would tearing apart any modern computer. Though the hardware will have something to do with this, it is not the primary focus of my irritation. Instead, I would like to start with the most hotly debated portion - the Operating System argument. Apple fans like to tout how OSX doesn't get viruses and malware infections; this is a bold-faced lie. Though the list of vulnerabilities is not as long as that of Windows (by FAR), that doesn't make it the invincible operating system. Even Linux distributions have their downsides when it comes to security, and I'm sure the percentage of Linux users is far lower than Mac users, let alone PC users. In any case, some simple maintenance and basic know-how will easily help prevent you from infections, but that is a different post for a different time.
So what about hardware? Well, that's an interesting thought, and I will actually approach it from the software standpoint to state my position on this one. If you say the term "Vista" to the average end user, they will most likely cringe. Let's be honest....the Vista rollout seems to be one of Microsoft's biggest blunders ever. However, unlike popular belief, they are not to blame as much as we think. Microsoft has been demonized for Vista because it was launched before the driver packages for it were complete. Are they partially to blame for this? Sure, but certainly not ALL of the blame lands upon them. The thing you have to realize is exactly how a driver works. With a PC, you have almost infinite combinations of parts and configurations, whereas the parts selection for an Apple is very slim. The distinct disadvantage to this is that there is less opportunity for customization. The distinct advantage is less compatibility issues. Think about it - MS writes core drivers for how stuff should work with windows. These are distributed to hardware manufacturers so that they can expand on them and customize the driver package to work with specific nuances of their hardware design. But, just because PNY makes an awesome video card, that doesn't mean the software will play well with a Turtle Beach sound card, with a Gigabyte motherboard, with Corsair RAM, etc. The more possible combinations, the harder it is to make sure they play nice together. So, with this being released without extensive hardware testing, it was kind of a techie faux pas. It made a lot of people hate Vista, hate MS, and decide they wanted a Mac. This is the background for where I'm going with this.
With issue #1 out of the way, this leads into the next irritant the average PC user faces - the one that makes them think that it really doesn't "just work". The specific argument started off with notebook PC's (laptops), and that is where I make a very defining difference. I don't think most of the population has a HUGE irritation with PC's, especially built ones, when it comes to the PC vs. Mac debate, but lappys are where we run into major differences of opinion. Lots of people love the Macbook Pro, but they're kinda pricey. And not without reason. Apple doesn't cheap out on their parts to make a bunch of entry-level lappys. The Macbook Pro retails around $1500 for the base, or $2000 for a fairly good configuration. That is out of a lot of users' price range, which is why a lot of them don't buy one in the first place. However, I feel that price to be quite excessive. You do get what you pay for, to an extent, and that is why people are fed up with PC laptops - they're buying the wrong ones. A friend who has an Asus laptop commented on how his computer was in being repaired, and he had a high preference to the Macbook Pro that he was allowed to use in the meantime. No offense to his purchase decision, but this wasn't exactly the top-of-the-line Asus, either. When people buy the $300 WalMart Black Friday special, they aren't buying the high quality notebook they think they are. From a past life in which I worked for Dell (indirectly), I learned that the reason a lot of places can do that is because of just how much they cheap out on parts. Dell's notebooks fall into a few different categories - they don't normally market their business and corporate systems to the consumer market. In fact, they are made from very different components, and because of that, there is a difference in price (not to mention quality). For a similarly configured Dell Inspiron (consumer market system) and a Dell Latitude (business-class system), the Inspiron will cost anywhere from two-thirds to half the price of the Latitude. But, it makes a difference. We had all sorts of strange issues with the Inspirons. I personally would never own a consumer-market Dell laptop because they just aren't very good, but I would buy another Latitude in a heartbeat. There are currently 4 Latitudes of varying ages and generations in my house, and they all still run great with almost no issues (old batteries and 1 failed wireless card aside). A $1200 Lenovo Thinkpad will definitely have a longer life than a $300 Acer Aspire, and that is the point I am trying to get across here.
Again, to make sure you understand that I am not trying to dissuade people from buying a Mac, I just don't think people should assume they are going to solve all of your computer woes. They will just give you a different set of woes.
Because of this, a friend of mine and I are going to start up a little blog and do some rigorous hardware and software testing between a commercial-grade PC Laptop and a Macbook Pro. We want to see if the Macbook is really worth the pricetag difference for exactly what you get for the price. Does the aluminum case make the difference in durability? Is Windows 7 really a good alternative to OS:X and vice-versa? We're about to find out which one gets you more bang for your buck.
To be continued.....
Showing posts with label Windows 7. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Windows 7. Show all posts
Thursday, January 27, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)